The direction of this post is slightly different, and it might not be for everyone. Let me start by a quick definition of how I use the term ‘leaverite’, a term I was first introduced to by metallurgist John Glen from Burnie while discussing the mineralogy of an ore that proved to be too difficult to process. He quipped that it appeared that the owners had a few million tons of leaverite – leave it right there. There was no economic case to process it.
This is where an external party that can have a look at the facts without any involvement can be crucial. And we can help with this critical look.
I will look at how a lack of applied critical thinking, the investments and sacrifices already made, and the unwillingness to question the actual status and viability of a project can lead to an increasingly narrow view, where reality is discarded in favour of the narrative. A person stuck in this situation will ignore red flags to justify continuing with the investment of time and money, even when it is clear, from an outsider’s view, that there are no logical or factual reasons to continue.
The basic concept behind this behaviour extends past mining projects and into our daily lives. We have all been involved in projects where the time, money and emotional capital invested in a project meant that we continued to spend, because writing off the investment seemed too costly. But it ended up costing a lot more by the time we finally stopped.
I will write from a ‘we’ perspective, because most of us would have had situations were we have lived this experience, some more dramatic and more profound than others. I was fortunate (or unfortunate) enough to have learned this quite early on in my life.
I will start by looking at the human need to have meaning and purpose in our lives, like Viktor Frankl expressed in his book ‘Man in search of meaning’.
However, there is a difference between the need of having meaning and purpose in our lives, which is essential, and the desire for achievement and recognition for actions taken, and sacrifices and commitments made.
The latter expose us to the dangers that Yuval Noah Harari expresses, which is a commitment to a cause because of the sacrifices we already made. He references war, but I will focus here on the fact that this holds true for situations as varied as exploration and mining projects, industry, construction, relationships, home renovations, car restorations, etc.
If we miss the right point of terminating a ‘project’ (professional, personal or commercial), because we have already invested a lot, or because we had some success early on, we are much more likely to stay too longer, and we keep investing time, money and emotions. Like the frog that slowly boils in the water, because it is heated gradually.
Our justifications become more and more absurd to onlookers, but not to ourselves. We simply have invested so much in the ‘project’, that we often stay on until we have exhausted all options, sometimes wasting years and copious amounts of energy and money in the process.
To avoid this as much as possible, it is important that we constantly hone our critical thinking abilities, that we learn how to step away and step ‘outside’ of the situation. We need to put stop points into our project schedule to assess if we should continue, and how. And what is missing in terms of crucial information. And we need to be open enough to ask for help from someone whom we trust, and who is not directly involved, so that we get an honest assessment.
aAnd this brings me to two practical examples of leaverite deposits. I will focus on two nickel projects, both overseas, and both in difficult jurisdictions. The company’s involvement in one was terminated after spending a significant amount of money on, but in time to stop a larger investment.
On paper, the project looked good to management (Ni laterite with decent grade and tonnage). However, when I started digging into the data, I could see that project owners made some disingenuous choices in their calculations. These should have been picked up before, but it had looked too good in terms of the projected ROI (return on investment) and NPV (net present value), and the red flags were ignored. The density of the ore had been widely ‘adjusted’. Downward when calculating grade, and upward when calculating tonnage, making the deposit look like a high grade, high tonnage prospect, when it was in fact much lower grade and lower tonnage.
The other was also a Ni laterite project. In this case it was the mineralogy that stopped the project. Again, the project was in a difficult jurisdiction, and in this case, difficult terrain, requiring higher grade to make it a feasible proposition. The overall grade looked OK, and the deposit had been explored and drilled extensively. However, because the grade looked OK, the exploration company had not investigated how the Ni occurred. And when we looked at it, we found that it was almost evenly split between the highly refractory Ni spinel trevorite, and the typical Ni laterite minerals (serpentine, talc and chlorite). And with the Ni-bearing spinel being too fine to recover, this project was abandoned, too.
Please reach out if you want us to have a look at your project for an honest assessment.




