Cognitive biases in analytical technique selection.

Should you choose optical microscopy over automated mineralogy to save money? Not necessarily. Explore how sample representativity, analytical objectives, turnaround time and budget should guide the selection of mineralogical techniques.

Mineralogy Solutions Pty Ltd

8/12/20252 min read

Mineralogy Solutions Consultancy Process Minerolgy Exploration Minning XRD TIMA SEM
Mineralogy Solutions Consultancy Process Minerolgy Exploration Minning XRD TIMA SEM

I read a post recently which stated that QEMSCAN and TIMA, etc. shouldn’t be used early in a project, because it would mean spending thousands of dollars. Optical microscopy should be used instead, as this is a cheaper method, and the more costly techniques should be used at a more advanced stage.
The immediate response, echoed by comments, would be to agree. Conserving money early on, and using the money when the project is more advanced, does seems like the right idea, and in many cases, this is the best approach.
However, the comment and supporting argument to ‘swap automated mineralogy for optical microscopy, because it is cheaper and can differentiate between pyrite and marcasite’ made me stop and think. In this case you might use XRD, too.
Making assumptions and generalisations, and then employing reasoning that directly support our ideas and inclinations is a problem. We all are tempted to do it, but must avoid it. Proper evaluation of the unique set of circumstances surrounding the project is essential.
It feels like making a choice of hammer before finding out if we are indeed dealing with a nail, or if this is a screw.
Taking a step back, here are some suggestions on how to approach this in a more nuanced way.
The following is based on my experience, and it is probably incomplete. I look forward to suggestions, and a good discussion.
I will always ask a lot of questions before making any recommendation to a client, regardless of the stage of the project.
The initial questions, before any technique comes into the conversation, are these:
How representative are the samples you want to investigate, and how were they obtained?
There must be very specific reasons for investigating non-representative samples. And, in general, the money spent should positively correlate with representativity.

What do you need to know, and why do you need to know it?
This is the most crucial question. The answer can range from ‘I don’t know what the mineral is’ to ‘I need to understand the deportment specific elements in my ore’.

How quickly do you need a satisfactory answer?
This comes down to proper planning. However, there is no point sending samples off for an analysis that takes longer than your timeframe.

What are your budgetary constraints?
If money is an issue, the selection of samples and techniques needs to reflect that. However, no analytical technique should be chosen just because it fits within the budgetary constraints.

The answers to these questions often lead to more questions, but will eventually determine the technique(s) to use and the cost.

Overall, it is essential to understand the benefits and limitations of the analysis or analyses you might choose, the cost-benefit you get from the results in terms of how well the results correspond to your expectations and needs, and last but not least, the opportunity cost, which is driven by the timeframe in which results need to available

Independent. Experienced. Solutions focused.
Mineralogy Solutions Consultancy XRD TIMA SED analysis Liberation Process Mineralogy Exploration Mineralogy
Mineralogy Solutions Consultancy XRD TIMA SED analysis Liberation Process Mineralogy Exploration Mineralogy

© 2026 Mineralogy Solutions Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.